If you’re anything like me, you’ve probably spent countless hours in The Forge Roblox, grinding for ores and trying to craft that perfect weapon. I remember my first few attempts at forging—ending up with broken daggers and worn-out greatswords that couldn’t even scratch the tougher enemies. But after hundreds of crafting attempts and countless battles, I’ve finally cracked the code to becoming a master weaponsmith in The Forge.
Today, I’m sharing everything I’ve learned about the best weapons in The Forge, complete with a comprehensive tier list and detailed crafting guide that will transform you from a struggling novice into a forging legend. Trust me, once you understand these mechanics, you’ll be crafting masterwork weapons that make other players green with envy!
The Forge is one of those rare Roblox games that perfectly blends RPG progression with satisfying crafting mechanics. When I first jumped into this mining and forging adventure, I was immediately hooked by the depth of its systems. At its core, The Forge is about descending into dangerous caves, mining valuable ores, and then using those materials to craft powerful weapons and armor.
What makes The Forge stand out from other Roblox crafting games is its attention to detail. Every weapon you create feels unique, with its own stats, appearance, and forging requirements. The game doesn’t just hand you powerful gear—you have to earn it through skill, patience, and a bit of luck with the forging mini-games.
The community around The Forge has exploded recently, and for good reason. With regular updates adding new weapons, ores, and crafting mechanics, there’s always something new to discover. Whether you’re a solo player looking to dominate the caves or someone who enjoys the economic aspect of trading and selling rare weapons, The Forge offers something for everyone.
I’ll be honest—I wasn’t immediately sold on The Forge when I first tried it. The initial mining grind felt tedious, and my early crafting attempts were frustrating failures. But there’s something incredibly satisfying about the progression system that kept me coming back.
What really hooked me was that moment when I finally crafted my first masterwork weapon. After dozens of failed attempts and countless hours practicing the mini-games, seeing that “Masterwork” tag appear on a colossal sword I had forged myself was pure gaming bliss. The weapon looked incredible, handled perfectly in combat, and made previously challenging enemies feel like mere obstacles.
The social aspect is another huge draw. I’ve made some great friends in The Forge community, sharing tips about ore locations, crafting strategies, and showing off our latest creations. There’s nothing quite like the feeling of trading a rare weapon you crafted yourself for materials you need to create something even better.
But my favorite part has to be the constant sense of progression. Every time I play, I’m either getting better at the mini-games, discovering new ore combinations, or finding ways to optimize my weapon upgrades. The learning curve is steep, but that’s what makes mastering The Forge so rewarding.
Crafting in The Forge isn’t just about throwing ores into a forge and hoping for the best. After my early failures, I learned that successful weapon crafting requires strategy, skill, and understanding of the game’s mechanics. Let me walk you through my proven process for crafting legendary weapons.
The first thing you need to know is that weapon crafting in The Forge consists of several crucial steps. It all starts with gathering the right ores. Through my experience, I’ve found that not all ores are created equal. The rare ores—Cobalt, Lapis, Platinum, and Quartz—are your ticket to high-tier weapons.
When you’re ready to craft, head to The Forge area and interact with the crafting station. You’ll see different options for various weapon types. Here’s where strategy comes into play: the more high-quality ores you add, the better your chances of crafting powerful weapons. I’ve found that using a mix of the rarest ores gives me about a 70%+ chance of pulling a colossal sword—the best weapon class in the game.
This is where most players struggle, and where I initially failed repeatedly. The crafting process involves three critical mini-games that directly affect your weapon’s final quality:
The Bellows Mini-Game: You need to click and hold the green button while moving your mouse up and down rapidly to fill the meter. My pro tip? Use small, quick up-and-down motions rather than full-range movements. This technique fills the bar much faster and more efficiently, leading to better weapon quality.
The Casting Mini-Game: Keep the white wedge within the yellow zone as it moves up and down. The key here is anticipation—click just before the wedge reaches the edge of the yellow zone. I’ve found that staying near the center of the zone gives me the best results, as it accounts for sudden direction changes.
The Hammering Mini-Game: This is arguably the most challenging but also the most impactful. You need to click when the inner and outer circles align perfectly. My secret? Click slightly before the visual alignment occurs. There’s a slight input delay, so anticipating the perfect moment consistently yields “Perfect” hits.
Your performance in these mini-games determines the final quality of your weapon, which ranges from:
I’ve learned that aiming for at least “Excellent” quality is crucial for end-game content. Masterwork weapons are game-changers but require near-perfect performance in all mini-games.
After testing every weapon type extensively, I’ve developed a comprehensive tier list that reflects real combat performance, not just raw stats. This isn’t just about damage numbers—it’s about how these weapons actually perform in the heat of battle against tough enemies.
Colossal Swords These are without question the kings of The Forge. When I first crafted a Masterwork Colossal Sword, it completely changed my gameplay experience. The massive damage output combined with excellent range makes these weapons perfect for almost any situation.
Why they dominate: The combination of high damage, excellent range, and good stagger potential makes Colossal Swords the undisputed champions. Even with slower attack speeds, the per-hit damage more than compensates. I’ve cleared entire rooms of enemies that would have been nightmares with lesser weapons.
High-End Straight Swords If you prefer faster combat but still want respectable damage, these are your best bet. I’ve found that certain Straight Swords can rival even Colossal Swords in DPS when built correctly.
Why they’re excellent: The incredible attack speed of these weapons means you’re constantly dealing damage. While individual hits aren’t as devastating as Colossal Swords, the rapid-fire nature can overwhelm enemies before they can react. The Chaos sword, in particular, is a hidden gem that few players manage to craft due to its rarity.
Katanas I have a soft spot for Katanas—they were my go-to weapons before I discovered the power of Colossal Swords. They offer a nice balance of speed and damage, but ultimately fall short of the top tiers.
Great Swords These serve as excellent stepping stones to Colossal Swords. I used Great Swords extensively during my mid-game phase and found them reliable, if unspectacular.
Great Axes I wanted to love Great Axes—the idea of massive, sweeping attacks is appealing—but in practice, they’re just too slow and clunky. The damage is decent, but you’ll find yourself taking more hits than necessary.
Gauntlets These are fun for a change of pace, but the extremely short range makes them impractical for serious combat. I’ve tried maining Gauntlets for challenge runs, but wouldn’t recommend them for regular play.
Daggers Daggers might seem appealing due to their lightning-fast attack speed, but the damage is so pitiful that you’ll spend forever whittling down even basic enemies. I only recommend using these in your first hour of gameplay.
Scythes Despite their cool aesthetic, Scythes are the worst heavy weapon class. They combine slow attack speeds with mediocre damage, making them thoroughly outclassed by every other weapon type.
Crafting a great weapon is only half the battle. To truly dominate in The Forge, you need to understand the enhancement and rune systems. I’ve spent countless hours experimenting with different enhancement strategies, and I’m ready to share my most effective techniques.
Every weapon in The Forge can be enhanced using Essences and Gold, which are common drops from enemies. Each enhancement level increases your weapon’s damage, but more importantly, every three enhancement levels unlocks a new rune slot. This is crucial because runes can dramatically alter your weapon’s performance.
I’ve found that the sweet spot for most weapons is around +9 to +12 enhancement. Beyond this point, the resource cost becomes prohibitive for the marginal gains. However, for your absolute best weapons (like a Masterwork Colossal Sword), pushing to +15 or higher can be worth it.
Runes drop primarily from mining rocks and can give your weapons powerful passive abilities. Through extensive testing, I’ve identified several rune combinations that work exceptionally well:
For Colossal Swords: I recommend focusing on damage-increasing runes and area-of-effect effects. My current setup includes a Fire Damage rune that burns enemies over time and a Critical Strike rune that occasionally doubles my damage output.
For Fast Weapons (Straight Swords, Katanas): Speed and utility runes work best here. I’ve had great success with Life Steal runes on fast weapons, as the rapid attack rate means consistent healing during combat.
Pro Tip: Always save your best runes for Masterwork or Excellent quality weapons. Applying high-tier runes to Average or Poor quality weapons is a waste of valuable resources.
This is a question I struggled with early in my The Forge journey. When should you invest resources into enhancing an existing weapon versus crafting a new one? Here’s my rule of thumb:
Enhance if:
Craft new if:
One aspect of The Forge that many players overlook is the economic side of weapon management. I’ve learned that being smart about which weapons to sell and which to keep can dramatically accelerate your progression.
Several factors determine a weapon’s selling price:
I’ve found that Masterwork Colossal Swords can sell for thousands of gold, making them excellent income sources when you have duplicates or better options.
Here’s my personal approach to weapon management:
Pro Tip: Always enhance weapons to at least +3 before selling them. The small investment in enhancement often pays for itself many times over in increased sale value.
While The Forge doesn’t have traditional promo codes like some Roblox games, there are still ways to get free rewards and advantages. I’ve discovered several methods to give yourself an edge without spending real money.
One of the most valuable “freebies” in The Forge comes from race rerolls. Your character’s race can significantly impact your stats and playstyle, so getting the right race is crucial. I’ve found that the game occasionally grants free rerolls through:
Throughout my time playing The Forge, I’ve discovered several hidden reward sources:
The Forge is constantly evolving, with regular updates that introduce new weapons, mechanics, and balance changes. Staying on top of these updates is crucial for maintaining your competitive edge.
In the most recent update, several weapons received significant adjustments:
The developers have also made quality-of-life improvements to the crafting system:
After hundreds of hours in The Forge, I’ve accumulated a wealth of knowledge that goes beyond basic crafting and combat. Here are my most valuable tips for taking your game to the next level.
Efficient mining is the foundation of successful weapon crafting. I’ve developed several strategies to maximize my ore collection:
Having the best weapons means nothing if you can’t use them effectively in combat. Here are my combat strategies:
For Colossal Swords: Time your attacks carefully. The slow wind-up means you need to anticipate enemy movements. I’ve found that attacking just before enemies reach you gives the best results.
For Fast Weapons: Use your speed to your advantage. Circle around enemies while attacking, staying just outside their attack range. This hit-and-run tactic works wonders with Straight Swords and Katanas.
Resource Management: Always keep an eye on your stamina. Even the best weapons are useless if you’re too tired to swing them. I’ve learned to pace my attacks during extended combat sessions.
These are the techniques that separate good players from great ones:
Ore Combination Mastery: Certain ore combinations have hidden synergies. Through experimentation, I’ve discovered combinations that increase the chances of specific weapon types. For example, combining Platinum and Quartz seems to increase Colossal Sword drop rates.
Quality Control: If you’re having trouble with the mini-games, consider practicing with cheaper ores first. I often do “practice runs” with common ores to warm up before attempting to craft with rare materials.
Enhancement Timing: Enhance weapons immediately after crafting them if they have good potential. The enhancement bonus is calculated based on the weapon’s current stats, so enhancing early maximizes the benefit.
I’ve answered countless questions from newer players about The Forge’s mechanics. Here are the most common ones, along with my expert responses.
Based on my extensive testing, the Skull Crusher (Colossal Sword) is currently the best weapon in the game. With 24 base damage and excellent range, it outperforms everything else in most situations. However, the Chaos Straight Sword is a close second for players who prefer faster combat styles.
The key is using high-quality ores and mastering the mini-games. I’ve found that using a mix of Cobalt, Lapis, Platinum, and Quartz gives the best results. Also, adding more ores to the forge increases your chances of getting bulkier weapons like Colossal Swords.
Weapons need to be enhanced to at least +3 before they gain rune slots. Some rare weapons come with rune slots already unlocked, but most start without any. I recommend enhancing any weapon you plan to use long-term to at least +3 as soon as possible.
Yes, but focus on utility rather than perfection. Early game, I recommend crafting weapons that help you gather resources more efficiently rather than trying to craft the perfect weapon right away. Save your rarest ores for when you have better crafting skills.
Masterwork quality requires near-perfect performance in all three crafting mini-games. I’ve found that practice makes perfect—spend time mastering each mini-game individually before attempting full weapon crafts. The bellows mini-game is particularly important for achieving Masterwork quality.
This depends on your progression stage. Early game, sell everything except your current best weapon to fund upgrades. Mid to late game, keep a variety of weapon types for different situations, but don’t hesitate to sell duplicates or inferior quality weapons.
Mastering The Forge’s weapon crafting system has been one of the most rewarding gaming experiences I’ve had in Roblox. From those early frustrating attempts at crafting basic daggers to now consistently producing Masterwork Colossal Swords, the journey has been incredible.
What I love most about The Forge is how it rewards both skill and knowledge. Understanding the mechanics is important, but so is developing the actual skill to execute perfect mini-games and make smart strategic decisions about which weapons to craft, enhance, and sell.
I hope this comprehensive guide helps you on your own forging journey. Remember, practice makes perfect—don’t get discouraged if your first few crafting attempts don’t turn out perfectly. Even I still occasionally mess up the hammering mini-game or use the wrong ore combination.
The most important advice I can give is to experiment and find what works for your playstyle. While Colossal Swords might be objectively the best weapons, you might have more fun with the rapid-fire action of Straight Swords or the unique feel of Katanas. The Forge is about enjoying the process as much as the results.
Now it’s your turn! Grab your pickaxe, head into those caves, and start forging some legendary weapons. I’d love to hear about your crafting successes and the amazing weapons you create. Happy forging, and may your mini-games always be perfect!
Looking for more Roblox gaming guides? Check out our Megabonk weapons guide for another comprehensive tier list, or explore our 99 Nights in the Forest guides for more survival crafting strategies!
